BOLDED SCIENCE
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Posts By Category

Why is there no Cure for Cancer?

12/28/2020

2 Comments

 
Picture
Cell culture dish with pink liquid
In less than one-year, scientists created two vaccines with over 90% efficiency for Covid-19. Which begs the question, what gives? Why don't we have cures for all our other ailments? After spending billions of dollars on cancer research for decades, where is that cure? Regrettably, there is none. And it's not in a vault protected by the government and big pharma either. The reality is, cancer is extremely hard to treat, study, and understand.

Infectious disease vs. cancer
​

Infectious diseases are easily targeted in comparison to cancer cells. Bacteria have a unique cell wall compared to animal cells. Some antibacterial medications attack their cell wall synthesis, killing bacteria and minimally harming ourselves.
​
Viruses are also easily distinguished from our cells. They produce their own distinct proteins and have unique genes. We use vaccines to train our immune system to be alerted to their "foreign" presence.

But cancer cells? They're a bit trickier than bacteria and viruses.

What is cancer?

Cancer is a mass of our cells that have uncontrolled growth, avoidance of cell death, and the annoying habit of acquiring genetic mutations that enable unwanted behaviors. Ironically, killing a cancer cell is easy; we do it in test tubes all the time. The challenge is killing the cancer cells in the body without harming healthy cells. Unlike bacteria and viruses, cancer cells have our genes, our proteins, and our molecular machinery. So how do we kill cancer cells inside a human body?

The answer lies in the research. Through years and years of experimental research, we are learning what makes cancer cells tick. By figuring out how cancer cells behave differently, anti-cancer drugs can be designed that specifically kill cancer cells and do not harm non-cancer cells.  

What makes a cancer cell?

It all comes down to abnormalities in the DNA. Genetic mutations can be inherited from your parents, acquired over time due to general wear and tear, or result from environmental stress (cigarette smoke, UV, etc..). 

We have an increased susceptibility to cancer when an oncogene or tumor suppressor gene is mutated. Oncogenes are genes that contribute to cancer if they are over-expressed or hyper-activated, i.e., epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR). Tumor suppressors are genes that, if turned off, contribute to tumorigenesis. The most famous tumor suppressor is P53, a protein that signals cells to die. When P53 is weakened or inactivated, cells don't die when they are injured or malfunction, causing abnormal growth.

Having one mutation in an oncogene or a tumor suppressor increases the probability of getting cancer, but it won't cause cancer on its own. An estimated 2-6 cancer-related genes must be mutated for tumorigenesis, and further mutations can contribute to disease severity.

Barriers to treating cancer.

​Cancer is a heterogeneous disease. When we refer to cancer, we are not mentioning one disease, but a family of hundreds of diseases. A treatment that works well for breast cancer might not necessarily work for pancreatic. To complicate matters further, each tumor can be characterized by its unique genotype, meaning that not every patient will respond to treatment similarly.  

Cancer cells mutate and adapt. After wrapping your head around the infinite permutations of cancer types and genotypes, also consider that an individual tumor may be heterogeneous as well. Cancer cells divide so quickly in stressful environments that they often incorporate DNA mutations. Mutagenesis creates subpopulations within a tumor, causing issues such as metastasis and chemotherapy resistance. 

The difference is subtle. As mentioned, the drug designed to kill cancer cells shouldn't poison the rest of our body. But if the difference between the cancer cells and our cells are only 2-6 genetic mutations, designing a specific drug is no trivial task. Currently, most chemotherapies are designed with one of the following anti-cancer strategies:
  • Attack cell division: A hallmark of cancer is rapid cell division. A key component of cell division is complete replication of the cell's genome. Therefore, many cancer drugs impair DNA replication machinery, impede DNA repair proteins needed for replication, or create DNA damage that will block DNA replication. Unfortunately, these chemotherapies also attack healthy cells that divide quickly (hair, nails, muscle, and GI tract cells), causing common side effects like hair loss, loss of appetite, and fatigue. Toxicity to neuronal, kidney, and heart tissue is often the dose limitation for these drugs.
  • Target the mutated protein: Drugs can be designed to recognize the mutated protein specifically while having limited recognition of protein expressed in healthy cells. For example, inhibitors have been created for EGFR with activating mutations found in some non-small cell lung cancers. Additionally, vaccines targeting mutated KRAS proteins, commonly found in lung, colorectal, and pancreatic cancers, are undergoing clinical trials.
  • Induce synthetic lethality: Synthetic lethality is a phenomenon where disruption of two genes of similar function causes the cell to die, while only disrupting one of the genes allows the cells to live. The concept is simple, identify a mutated gene in cancer, and find a second gene to inhibit pharmaceutically to kill the cancer cell. The synthetic lethal concept was recently used to develop Parp inhibitors, a chemotherapy used to treat BRCA deficient cancers. The successful creation of Parp inhibitors jumpstarted a movement in cancer research to discover other genetic synthetic lethal relationships of genes commonly mutated in cancer.
Picture
Diagram of synthetic lethality. Disrupting both BRCA and Parpi genes cause cell death
Modeling Cancer. Early cancer research takes place in test tubes. Protein function and structure are investigated in solution, while cancer cells are manipulated in dishes. When in vitro studies seem promising, experimentation moves on to mouse models. Unfortunately, what works well in a test tube often does not work well in the body. And sometimes, a drug that works marvelously in a mouse is toxic to humans. Therefore, preclinical studies are tweaked and repeated extensively to ensure that clinical studies are as safe as possible. Computational models can help bridge the gap between animal testing and human testing, but with limitations.

On average, it takes 
30 years from drug design to clinical trial approval. And as careful as scientists are during those 30 years, cancer clinical trials have the highest failure rate. Most trials fail due to adverse side effects (aka: when the drug also attacks our healthy cells).

So, will there ever be a cure?

To answer that question, we'd have to define the word "cure." A cure is a gold-standard treatment to eradicate or alleviate a disease completely. To date, only two diseases have been successfully eradicated from the earth, smallpox and rinderpest (both viruses that were wiped out by vaccination — yay, vaccines!).

Likely an end-all cure to cancer is not in our near future. But wait! Before you close out of this blog post, annoyed by my pessimism, I have a message of hope for you. Although "cures" are not on our immediate horizon, adequate treatment and prevention are already here — with more to come. Let's look at breast cancer as an example. In 1971 the 5-year survival rate of all breast cancers was 53%. Today, the 5-year survival rate is nearing 90%! Encouraging numbers, to say the least, these stats are representative of the advancements made in cancer research.

Cancer researchers have chosen an arduous career, often riddled with disappointment and setbacks. Although earth-shattering, groundbreaking discoveries are preferred, in science, it's often the small victories that will culminate in clinically relevant treatments. Cancer research may seem slow, but it is undoubtedly progressing.

Author

Kerry McPherson, @KerrySilvaMcph 
PhD Candidate studying biomedical sciences. Researches proteins implicated in cancer chemoresistance. Bolded Science creator and editor. Also co-founded a STEM education outreach program at her University.

Picture
2 Comments
Danko Antolovic
2/17/2021 04:16:24 am

Thanks for this very informative article.

Here is a (somewhat amateur) observation. All single-cell organisms are in effect immortal, in that they continuously divide. In order for the first differentiated multi-cellular organisms to come about, some early colony of slime mold (or something) had to bring cell division under organism-wide control. There had to be an immortality-suppression mechanism, probably responsive to some chemical signals within the colony. In today's creatures, we see cells proliferating and dying in an orderly way, under just such signals.

So this mechanism is widely prevalent, and as old as multi-cell organisms. I would assume that the core part of it, whatever it is, must be fairly stable evolutionarily and common to all cells, since a multi-cell creature can't even begin to develop without it.

Cancer appears like a local reversal to uninhibited cell division, a breakdown of the immortality suppression. Prevention or repair of that breakdown, if possible, would seem like a promising general approach to the problem. How much is actually known about this, and are researchers pursuing such lines of investigation to any extent?

Reply
Kerry McPherson
2/17/2021 01:23:53 pm

Firstly, yes, you summarized the issue at hand elegantly. And yes! Researchers are trying to both prevent and treat the reversal.

Prevention mostly comes in limiting exposure to DNA damage that could lead to the problem (antioxidants, no smoking etc...). As for reversing the mechanism, many chemotherapies in development attempt to inhibit cell growth receptors and cell growth transducers.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Archives

    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Posts By Category